What dis sposed to be? "Finger puppet"

Last night, after the DCist photography opening and some bangin ass tortilla soup, O. Horse, Penelope, Icky Woods, and his babe played some late-night, homemade Pictionary.  Icky and Horse made an amazing comeback, roaring back from a 16-point deficit to win in the final round. 

Icky did proffer one curious interpretation of a clue, and O. Horse was stumped for the full one and a half minutes.  Given that the game was winding down and the score was tight, Icky became irate and cussed Horse out for not being able to guess what his drawing was.

So, to settle our argument as to whether Icky's a bad drawer or Horse is a bad guesser, I asked folks to guess what it was.  Nobody even came close--see for yourself in the comments section.  I guess nobody could tell what that damn thing was.  Finger puppet?